Episodes
Best ABBA Song
Swedish super group ABBA won the Eurovision Song Contest and took the world by storm with a series of incredible pop and dance tracks in the 1970s and 80s. We look back on the bandβs most popular tracks.
Best Drinking Song
Our 2025 Summer Specials continue with a frothy conversation about 16 of the most-loved songs about alcohol, or about drinking alcohol. Bottoms up β but please drink responsibly.
Best Billy Joel Single
Billy Joel became a massive pop and rock star in the 1970s, and remained one of the most successful musicians in the world for nearly 20 years after that. While he largely retired from recording new music in the 1990s, he continues to sell out stadiums and delight millions on primetime television 50 years after his debut. We look back on his biggest hit singles.
Best Song of 2015
Itβs already been 10 years since the songs of 2015 ruled the airwaves and music-streaming apps. We look back at 16 of the most-popular, and most critically acclaimed, songs from the midpoint of the 2010s.
Best Song of 1978
We kick off our 2025 Patreon-sponsored episodes with a look at 16 of some of the most iconic songs that ruled the airwaves in 1978.
Best Of 2024: Music
Best of 2024 Music features picks from panelists of their favorite albums of the year, everything from pop to rock to jazz fusion and absurdist bands.
Best Grammy Winner for Best New Artist
Since the 1960s the Grammys have presented Best New Artist to breakthrough singers and musicians. Along the way, the award has gone to people who would become among musicβs brightest stars. We debate 16 of them to determine the very best.
Best Celine Dion Song
Celine Dion is one of the greatest vocalists of all time, and one of the defining voices of the late 20th and early 21st centuries. We celebrate her incredible catalogue by discussing 16 of her biggest hits to determine the very best Celine Dion song.
Best Tina Turner Song
Tina Turner was one of the most important -- and longest-lasting -- stars of the late 20th Century. Her music and her story inspired millions around the world over the course of her seven-decade career. As part of our Divas series, we explore the very best of her catalogue.
Best Britney Spears Music Video
Britney Spears is one of the definitive music video artists of the 21st Century. In honor of the 25th anniversary of her "Baby One More Time" album release, we look back at 16 of Britney's most iconic music videos and name the Best Britney Video.
Best Solo Musician to Come Out of a Band
Some of the biggest stars in music were once members of popular bands. For this episode the podcast discusses 16 of the stars who went supernova after leaving their group.
Best Girl Group
Get ready to harmonize! The panel discusses 16 of the most iconic girl groups of all time, from the OGs of the 1960s to the K-Pop of BLACKPINK and everything in between.
Best Song of 2003
Weβre throwing it back to the early 2000s as the podcast discusses 16 of the most memorable tracks from 2003. You can find us in the club, or in the backyard, with all the boys our milkshake has brought.
Best Song of 1985
In this special brothers-only episode, the panel debates 16 of the biggest songs from 1985, narrowing them down to the best of the bunch.
Best Boy Band
The panelists discuss 16 of the most popular boy bands from pop music present and the past, in a spicy debate that nearly ends decades-long friendships!
Best Holiday Pop Song (1980-2020)
The panelists get into the holiday spirit by debating 32 of the holliest, jolliest holiday pop songs of the past 40 years.