Jonathan Larson’s “Rent” changed Broadway musicals forever. The groundbreaking show celebrates its 30th anniversary this year, and we aim to name its very best song.

Lin-Manuel Miranda’s celebrates a decade on Broadway in 2025. In honor of the Tony-, Grammy-, and Pulitzer Prize-winning musical, we look back on 16 of its most beloved songs.

The panelists strike up the band and cue up the chorus as they debate the best Broadway musicals that have won the Tony Award for Best Musical, from the 1950s through 2019.