Hop in the Great Pop Culture Debate time machine and join host Eric Rezsnyak and panelists Amy Pilott, Heather Maclean, and Kara Austin as they look back at the final Billboard Hot 200 of the 20th Century to determine which pop song was the very best of 1999. Make sure you come back for Part 2, where the panel makes its final decision (featuring sick beats by Babyface). Want to listen to all the songs that made up the bracket? We’ve got a playlist for that! Click here.

Want to play along at home? Here’s the Listener Bracket! Go to File > Make a Copy, fill it out, and then see how your picks stack up against our panel.