It’s Week 9, the semi-finals, and only four bakers remain. Last week, frontrunner Tom took a tumble, while Moyin snagged his first Star Baker title. Can Gabe get his shit together long enough to make it through? Will Mo reveal that he had a personality beyond calling things old all along? Whose bakes will reign supreme? Let’s have some patisserie, oui oui!
Read on for my take on Episode 8 of “Great British Bake-Off” (AKA “Great British Baking Show” for us American swine) Season 17. SPOILERS AHEAD!
RELATED CONTENT
Best “Great British Baking Show” Bake
The Signature: Gaga for Baba
The Challenge: Twelve elegantly decorated BABAS. Alison’s accent was so strong, I had to rewind and try that again. BABA.
The Lineup
Moyin - Zobo (WTF is that?!) babas - a hibiscus tea soaked baba. I feel like I’m watching this in a totally foreign language.
Mo - I’ve-Never-Had-a-Baba-Basic-Ass Lemon baba. Ground-ba-breaking. I’m so tired of his personality.
Tom - Took a week off work to prepare for his limoncello baba with a chantilly cream. I love his devotion, and it’s absolutely what I would have done.
Gabe - Basic Hazelnut Babas filled with a vanilla creme patissiere. While the show may have called them basic, they seem more challenging than Mo’s choice.
The Chaos
Wet bread. Yum. Babas are made with a yeasted, proved dough that takes time to prepare.
Mo shares that as a Muslim, he doesn’t drink alcohol, which does make it difficult in that he can’t taste his syrup. But only Moyin’s alcoholic bake is enough to cross Alison’s eyes.
The tent is apparently broiling, allowing several to skip the electronic proving drawers and just rely on the elements of a 34-degree Celsius (that’s 93 degrees Fahrenheit!) tent. I’m glad it’s not Chocolate Week (shout out to GPCD Panelist, Amma Marfo! She knows why.)
Mo is burning honey for his bake, something I’ve actually never heard of before. I’m intrigued by that flavor profile. He also shares that he relied on TikTok to learn how to bake his baba. I am terrified for the future of our world.
With time running out and all four bakers plating, everyone’s babas look truly baba-beautiful. (I’ll stop, I swear.)
The Signature Verdict
Good: NOBODY.
Somewhere in Between: EVERYBODY. Moyin - good proof, nice piping, but a bit too boozy. SQUIRTS; Tom - Underproofed, but heavenly lemon flavors; Gabe - Dry, tight holes. A top’s delight; a baba baker’s nightmare; Mo - Flavor great, but the sugary crunch on an overbaked bread made it too unlike a baba.
Bad: Surprisingly, nobody.
The Technical: Frigid French Fuckery
The Challenge: Gateau Concorde, a French delicacy that sounds intense and impossible. Multiple meringue layers filled with dark chocolate mousse, surrounded by chocolate meringue cylinders. I guess I spoke too soon about chocolate week… This does not look like something a homebaker could make.
The Drama
For once, I agree with Mo’s totally flat affect - if I were on an expensive plane, I would want something more than just meringue and mousse.
The recipe provided does not seemingly provide much direction, outside of buzzwords like pâte à bombe - an egg yolk with a syrup. After Moyin finishes his, it looks like a certain scene out of Jurassic Park with Jeff Goldblum and a large pile.
Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome to the stage - Bain Marie!
After baking, the bakers have varying levels of success with their meringuerie. Some cracks are showing as they begin the assembly.
Moyin is in trouble, as his mousse is loose - and while that sounds like fun, it’s problematic. The stress is clearly getting to him.
In the final minutes of decoration, nothing is looking particularly impressive, with Moyin’s looking especially Stonehengey. Let’s see what the judges think.
The Technical Rankings
4th Place: Moyin - An outright disaster - the meringue is dense, and the mousse is watery
3rd Place: Gabe - Lacking flavor
2nd Place: Tom - Mousse needed a bit more air
1st Place: Mo - Not bad at all (definitely what you want to hear)
The Showstopper: How Ya Doin’, Baby Cakes?
The Challenge: A beautiful, spectacular showcase of twelve, highly-decorated, themed petit gateaux.
The Highlights & Disasters
The pressure is on, as just one small mistake will send someone home. The judges are looking for Parisian perfection. They’ve certainly ratcheted up the heat this week.
Gabe - Gabe’s Garden Greenhouse Gateaux - Tomatoes and radish-shaped goodies with fruit fillings.
Moyin - The Forbidden Fruit - a nougatine basket filled with orange cremeux-filled oranges and spiced apple-filled apples.
Mo - A Mango Mousse Moment - A box filled with three fruit-shaped petit gâteaux - mango, blueberry, and mixed berry.
Tom - Ever the overachiever, Tom is making a Wizard of Oz/Wicked mashup with Glenda- and Elphaba-themed raspberry/almond and pistachio/cherry petit gâteaux, traveling on the yellow brick road to a nougatine Emerald City. Tom: Inspired by a pub crawl, Tom is building his neighborhood pub out of almond and hazelnut nougatine, as well as a hazelnut-centric dessert.
With one hour left, every baker is still up against the clock. Each person has taken on so much, but probably no one more than Tom. Will he be able to finish it all in time?
Where most bakers are using rulers to ensure clean lines and equal measurements, Gabe is baking off vibes.
While Mo’s white chocolate box looks clean and nice, I have a hard time looking beyond the fact that… it’s a box. But perhaps he is the wise one not to take on more than he can handle.
The time pressure is clear, as both Moyin and Gabe are forced to mash their bakes together by hand when they won’t come out of the molds.
Judging:
Mo: I’m sorry, it’s underwhelming. I don’t care what the judges say. The fruits themselves look lovely - the mango/passion fruit tastes lovely; the raspberry needs more compote, but is delicious; the blueberry is a triumph as well. Overall, a resounding success - per the judges. Curtis, the bitchy judge, deducts points for creativity.
Gabe: It looks impressive, while wobbly. The “veggies” are adorable. The strawberry/basil bake works well, but needs a bit more flavor; the radish’s flavors are dwarfed by the white chocolate and let down by the lack of peppercorn.
Moyin: The basket is lovely. The orange oranges are cloudlike, but veer toward artificial in flavor; the apple apples aren’t as refined as they should be: patisserie isn’t chunky.
Tom: It is impactful to look at, with delicious nougatine that’ll turn your mouth green. “Elphaba” was a bit too thick, while “Glinda” needed more contrast and flavor action. Nigella even used the phrase “a childish palate” to describe many of Tom’s bakes.
Tom is definitely my favorite baker this season, so perhaps I’m being overly defensive because of that, BUT - the judges were 10x harsher to him than they were to any other baker.
The Final Verdict
Star Baker: Spoiled before we even made it away from the judge’s table, Mo is moving on to the final. Wahoo. I am as excited about that as he is.
Eliminated: After a few weeks of flavor trouble, the vibes fall short, and Gabe exits the tent. I think he should be proud of himself for making it to the semi-final.
Questions for Next Week
Next week’s the final! Who will take home this season’s pie plate? As Paul Hollywood said, GAME ON!
What do YOU think of “GBBO” Season 17? Drop your comments below!
